Tweet

Expectations or Incentives

Written by: Dale Furtwengler

Article Overview: "I've tried every incentive program imaginable and the only thing I've accomplished is creating divisiveness in my organization." Business Owner

Expectations or Incentives

Are Your Employees Not Performing to Expectations? It’s Time To Find Out Why!





A new client said to me, "I have tried every incentive imaginable and the only thing I accomplished is divisiveness in my organization". We have all heard horror stories about ill-designed incentives and the problems they create; however, this situation was different. This client was trying to use incentives to get people to do what was already expected of them. While that may seem strange, I can assure you that it is a common occurrence.

How do these situations arise? Are incentives the appropriate answer? If not, what should you, as business owners and managers, do to get the results you expect? There are several reasons why employees may not be performing to expectation. Here are a few.



Poorly communicated expectations

Most of you communicate your expectations, but the communication is not as complete as it should be. One of the most frequently omitted pieces of information is the deadline (I’d like this by 10:00 am Friday morning). Another component often missing from the communiqué is the "why" behind your request. Most employees will rise to the challenge of the most difficult deadlines if they understand the project's importance.



Inappropriate priority decisions

As business owners and managers, you need to investigate an individual's workload prior to assigning new tasks and setting deadlines. If you assign additional work without considering the employee's current workload, the employee has only two choices :

• make the new task a priority and let everything else slide
• let the new task slide

Either way the responsibility for assigning priorities is placed on an employee who typically has not been told "why" this project is important or what its relative importance is to the other projects he or she is expected to complete. This creates a lose-lose situation for the employee. Why? Because they don’t have the same information you do. The odds of their priorities coinciding with yours approaches zero.

Another risk associated with letting your employees set priorities is that they typically do first that which they enjoy most. It’s human nature! Now what do you think the chances are of getting what you want in the time frame you want? Nil?

Lack of follow up

Every business owner and manager I know wants to assign work then walk away knowing that it will be done. You don’t like to waste time following up, do you? Of course not, but if you don’t follow up on the due date, your employees are going to make one of two assumptions about your request. They are going to think that you are either building cushions into your due dates because you don’t trust them or flexing your authoritative muscle.

Either way, they resent having their schedules destroyed by management's whim, which is exactly how they view lack of follow up. Yes, I realize that you have a zillion other things on your mind, but your employees haven’t run a business so they don’t understand the myriad of decisions you face everyday. Another advantage of follow up is that the employees have an opportunity to receive more timely feedback, praise or constructive criticism, regarding their efforts. This is the most effective way to minimize future disappointments for both of you. This feedback mechanism is an excellent tool for creating behavioral changes that will allow your employees to meet more deadlines and minimize your follow up.

Unwillingness to use the axe

How often do you hear the question, "Why can't people just do what you ask of them?" You may have uttered it yourself. Often the individuals asking the question are unwilling to terminate employees who, despite repeated attempts to coach them to better performance, consistently fail to perform according to expectations.

If you truly want to minimize the time you spend following up on assignments, (NOTE: I said minimize, not eliminate), you must be willing to take appropriate action when your efforts exceed those of the employee in trying to improve his or her performance. Failure to eliminate underperformers causes the remainder of the organization to migrate to that lower level of performance. Every solid performer in your organization will eventually ask, “Who’s stupid here – the people who refuse to perform and still get to keep their jobs or me?” The best employees will eventually leave because they know your organization isn’t going anywhere with these deadbeats blocking the way.

Now, I am not suggesting that you run out and fire everyone who has missed a deadline (you could be lonelier than the Maytag repairman). I AM suggesting that you take those underperformers aside and let them know that you no longer intend to allow them to miss deadlines and performance goals. That’s fair! You are, after all, changing your operating policy. Then, if they don’t come around, let them go.

Incentives

Incentives should be designed to reward exceptional performance. A well-constructed incentive will reward the employee AFTER the company has benefited from his/her achievements. I am a strong believer in incentives, but it is easy to make mistakes in creating these programs. Here are a few design tips for you:

• involve employees in setting the performance goals – it creates buy-in for the goals
• make sure the goals are stretch goals
• create at least 3 or 4 goals so that the employees don’t become too narrowly focused
• establish firm deadlines for achievement of the goals
• create a simple feedback system so that employees can monitor their own progress
• weight each of the goals according to importance
• make sure the employees understand and are aware of this weighting – this helps them understand how the incentive compensation will be calculated
• make sure you understand what the company’s gaining
• pay out only a percentage of that gain

Additional tips

Let the employees know up front that as goals are achieved, new goals will become the focus of the incentive program. They need to understand that the company’s success, as well as their own, depends on life-long learning and skill development. The incentive program is designed to achieve these goals.

Don’t stay with a flawed program. Once you and your employees determine that you have made a mistake, fix it. They don’t want to waste their time and skills on unproductive efforts any more than you do. Not only that, they know that if their achievements don’t produce bottom line results there won’t be any money to pay the incentive.

Finally, wear the employee’s hat. Ask yourself, how can I abuse the incentive program that my employees and I just designed. There are always one or two people who push the envelope. If the risks are minimal, run with the program. If not, revisit those aspects of the program involving the greatest risk. Remember, no program is foolproof.

The right tool

Make sure that you are using the right tool for the job. If you aren't getting what would "normally" be expected, use the stick (expectations), not the carrot (incentives). If you want exceptional results, use incentives that pay after those results are achieved.

Copyright © 1999, Dale Furtwengler, all rights reserved

Related Articles
  Ten Ways to Drive Sales
  How to use customer incentives to dramatically increase customer loyalty
  How to build customer loyalty
  What Are The Results of A Recent Poll?
  3 Key Tips on How to Make Sales Incentives Work for Your Business"

Article Tags: business owners, divisiveness, expectation, horror stories, incentives, letter spacing, nbsp, occurrence, span style, style font, times new roman, white space



Related Forum Posts
Re: Finding AND Keeping Good People - Employee retention or as you mention “Keeping the Good People” is one of the biggest challenges for any growing business. It takes a huge effort from the entrepreneur’s end. I can come up with the following when it comes to KEEPing the good people- 1. Motivation of the employees 2. Recognition of the needs of the employees 3. Activities to make the employees feel valuable towards the organization 4. Make benefits more accessible 5. Offer profit sharing incentives 6. Create clear career paths at the company 7. Consider telecommuting, job sharing and other flexible working arrangements 8. Incentives are essential and they don't have to be huge 9. Have other managers praise an employee's work 10. Be sensitive to the balance between work and private life
Re: looking for partner - Partnerships in business can be tricky. Most partnerships fail. Here are a few points to ponder before starting a partnership: - Should have common goal and vision - Level of commitment in business - Expectations from business and each other. - Good sense of self-worth - Financial Position – Have a good experience in related business with strong financial standing I suggest you to go on Google type “Partnership Assessment form” and Partnership Assessment Tool” You find some good results. Further apart from this forum look into on social media and business sites.
Re: Non-profit Organizations - I helped set up a non-profit charity for helping stray pets and people who had lost their pets in our local area last year. There are so many things I learned from the experience, I'm not sure where to start. First of all, I hold to the teaching if you can dream it, you can do it! In one way, it was incredibly easy to find support for something we were so passionate about. On the other hand, our passion needed to be tampered with reason so that we didn't burn ourselves out. It is so important to set things in order as soon as possible. There should be an official board of directors and at least general protocols set in place for key services. Expectations among board members should be clear. Keep non-urgent decision making to during meetings only! Otherwise, you will be working 24 hours a day! And make sure you use your volunteers as soon as you get clarity on your first steps. Clarify your message as a whole before you take it to the public. Otherwise, you will create confusion on what you do or don't do. It was really helpful to connect with other organizations in the area who had a similar mission. In our case, we met with the SPCA so we could avoid doubling up on services and instead fill in the gaps of what they were unable to provide in our area. Fundraising IS important, but make sure you are keeping up with the services you offer. The mission of your organization is the priority. In a nutshell, setting up a charity was a great experience, but I certainly didn't need to work as hard as I did. I plan on doing it again in about 2 years where I will set up a charity to help women in both Canada and Third World countries.


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How To Calculate A Minimum Fee For Your Services

What Type of Business Should I Start?

How to Set Sales Goals that Work

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.