Tweet

The Discount Economy and It's Implications for the Future

Guest post by: Dale Furtwengler

Article Overview: What is the discount economy? How did we get here? More importantly, how do we get out?

The Discount Economy and It's Implications for the Future

We’ve been in a discount economy for several decades. There are a number of factors contributing to this reality:

• Market saturation in developed countries requiring the creation of higher paying jobs in developing countries.
• Six Sigma and Lean Manufacturing practices for removing fat from processes.
• Walmart’s low-price strategy.

The intent of these efforts is laudable. Creating new jobs, and consequently, new markets in developing countries produces long-term benefits for all of us. Removing waste from inefficient processes improves resource utilization and, typically, creates a healthier economy. Walmart’s low-prices are designed to increase its customers’ buying power. As I said, all laudable goals.

In pursuing these goals, Walmart and companies engaged in Six Sigma and Lean Manufacturing cost-reduction strategies placed a great deal of pressure on their suppliers to lower their prices. During this process we, as a society, became obsessed with low prices. So much so that we’ve lost sight of value. What are the implications of this loss?

We’ve hampered economic growth, not just in the U.S., but in all developed countries. In order to offer lower prices companies have to reduce costs. Since the largest cost for most companies is labor, it means that, in the past decade, salaries have actually declined leaving employees with less discretionary income to spend. The lack of discretionary funds limits economic growth by limiting spending to essentials. In terms of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, the discount economy is driving ever-increasing numbers of people in developed countries toward the physiological (survival) needs and away from the self-actualization peak we desire.

One side effect of this discount economy is that we’re devaluing education. For a dozen years or so I’ve worked with juniors and seniors in a local high school to help them gain an understanding of how business works. In the past two years I’ve repeatedly been asked “Is it worthwhile to get an MBA?” That doesn’t bode well for the United States’ ability to compete in the future. I can’t help but wonder whether students in other developed countries are asking the same question.

Combine the question of whether there is sufficient ROI on education with declining salaries, less discretionary income and lower profit margins and we are poised to experience:

• A paucity of talent.
• Lower R&D investments.
• Less innovation.
• Difficulty in competing globally in the future.
• A diminished lifestyle.

I doubt that this is the future any of us wants for ourselves much less for our children. There is a remedy. Companies need to refocus their and their buyers’ attention on value. Specifically they need to:

• Quantify the value they’re providing.
• Create sales scripts that educate buyers’ on value.
• Hold their prices in the face of buyer pressure to lower them.
• Avoid the market-share trap.
• Develop marketing messages to attract the buyers who value what they offer.
• Invest profits in finding new ways to serve the customers who value what they offer.

One of the reasons most of my clients feel trapped by industry pricing is that they don’t know how to quantify value. So the first step in the process is to discover how to do those calculations. Those formulae appear in my book, Pricing for Profit. The second mistake they make is to look at their competitors when determining what pricing is available to them. A better approach is to look at the price premiums that non-competing businesses are getting for their offerings.

The sales scripts that are used by most salespeople talk about a broad array of benefits, each of which is difficult for both the seller and buyer to quantify. In reality there are only three things that any organization sells - image, innovation or time-savings. Once sellers understand what they’re selling it’s much easier to quantify and communicate their value to their customers which helps their customers make better buying decisions.

Holding prices in the face of buyer pressure requires a clear understanding of what your most profitable customers value and the ability to say “No” to buyers who don’t fit that profile. There are simple scripts that allow sellers to exit gracefully from prospects who don’t fit the profile while retaining a good relationship and positive impression with that person - an impression that often translates into quality referrals.

Unfortunately many companies get caught in the “market share” trap - they get so caught up in who has the most customers that they lose sight of who their ideal customers are. This trap causes them to lower prices to increase customer head count. In essence, they’re reducing their revenues from their ideal customers to garner lower revenues and profit margins from customers who don’t really value what they offer and they increase their infrastructure cost to handle the additional volume - nasty one-two punch that we inflict upon ourselves.

Because companies lose sight of their ideal customers, their marketing messages become less effective, their marketing costs rise and their ROI on marketing declines.

Finally, companies invest in expansions that don’t make sense because they can’t identify new ways to serve their existing customer base. We need look no farther than Walmart’s, and now Target’s, entry into the grocery business. Both companies are or have moved into an industry that sports 5% lower gross margins and low to mid single digit operating margins.

Expansion should be designed to enhance profit margins, not cut into them. Companies that have money to invest need to find new and innovative ways to serve their existing ideal customer base. They shouldn’t invest in offerings that don’t add at least as much value as they’re currently offering. That value is evidenced by profit margins.

We have two choices available to us as we move forward in the current recovery. We can wait for the recovery to progress at its naturally slow pace or we can accelerate the recovery through modest price increase and utilization of the higher profits to invest in new and exciting ways to serve our ideal customers while accelerating job creation.

Related Articles
  A Behaviour Change Model
  Succeeding in a Challenging Economy
  Earth Day 2010: Life and Death Decisions for Business
  The Dangers of Discounting
  Mike Krause’s Sales Sense #14: Discount Doom! How much is enough?
  Does offshoring mean developed countries are losing technical jobs to developing countries?
  What's The Best Structure For A Pre-VC Investment?
  Factoring and Working Capital Financing in Canada – Do I know my’ Cost of Credit’?
  Get rewarded properly from your credit card
  Is your business protected?
  A Bad Economy Doesn't Mean Stick Your Head In The Sand
  1.0 Recent Economic Trends and Prospects for 2007: Economic Report on Africa 2007
  The prospect of employment in the year 2020 and beyond
  Ten Ways for Small Businesses to Cut Costs
  Dental Care Insurance For The Self Employed
  Reserves and Provisions
  Ad battling in a crisis
  How To Valuate Your Business
  Marketing In A Poor Economy
  How to Turn a Request for a Discount to Your Advantage

Article Tags: branding, marketing strategy, price strategy, pricing strategies, strategy of pricing, value based, value pricing



Related Forum Posts
How to valuate a business - Hi Garth - here is how we did it at Northern Crown Capital when I was helping them raise venture capital for Toronto-based entrepreneurs. Assume the start date is 2003 so 2008 projections are 5 years out: How Northern Crown Capital Valuates a Business 2008 Financial Projections Earnings Before Tax $5,865,000 Tax Rate 42% Taxes $2,463,300 Net Earnings $3,401,700 Amount Seeking to Raise Today $3,500,000 Discounted Value of Future Opportunity, 5 Years Out 2008 P/E Ratio 15 Value of Company in 2008 $51,025,500 Discount Rate Applied 30% Year 2008 $51,025,500 Year 2007 $35,717,850 Year 2006 $25,002,495 Year 2005 $17,501,747 Year 2004 $12,251,223 Value of Company at Investment in 2003 $12,251,223 Less: Investment Amount $3,500,000 Present Value $8,751,223 Discount for Risk & Private Company 40% Less: Discount for Risk & Private Company $3,500,489 Private Company Value $5,250,734 Present Value (What the Owner Keeps) $5,250,734 60.00% Financing (What the Investor Gets) $3,500,000 40.00% Total $8,750,734 100.00% I hope this helps!
Future Financial Corporation - I've never heard of Future Financial Corporation is this a new company?
Re: How do you back up your computer? - Seems like backup has definitely hit a nerve. Evan, thanks for sharing your experience with the Backblaze service. Regarding the time it takes to backup: * The initial backup will take a little while (one to two weeks for most users) depending on your Internet upload connection and the amount of data you have. You can click the "How long will my first backup take?" link to find out the estimate for you. * Future backups will be very quick as Backblaze will only backup new files and the pieces of those that have changed. Thanks! Gleb
Patent Walk-Through - Hello everyone! My name is Alex, I'm 18 years old and I'm constantly drawing up new ideas and inventing stuff. I sketch stuff down everywhere I go and on anything I can write on. I'm a big member of our local Future Business Leaders of America chapter (FBLA). In the future I hope to work my way up to being a Venture Capitalist. I think of myself as a pretty creative person who is very motivated. Some of the ideas and inventions I come up with are pretty far out but others I consider marketable and to have great potential. Being 18, I have little to no connections and no resources. I've been surfing this site pretty frequently for the last year and have finally decided to join the forum group. Anyway, here's my question... Basically, I have no idea how to get a patent together the costs and the overall process. As of now, I think I have a great idea that, as far as I know has not, ever been done before. I'm really excited about this idea. I'm a total novice at this and am willing to learn all that I can. Any information that you can provide me with would be great. Again the main things I want to know are: 1.Overall Process. 2.How Long It Takes. 3.Costs. 4.Anything That You Think I Should Know. 5.Tips/Experiences. 6.Confidentiality. 7.Must I Make A Physical Model of My Idea? Thanks guys! -Alex
Re: your personality type? - Hi Zac, If you're on the fence about 2 and 3, I'd think more about them. Big picture people tend to be oblivious to the detail of what is happening NOW -- the colors on a restaurant wall, the layout of someone's apartment, the color of people's shirts at a party, etc. They instead notice the "theme" -- an upscale restaurant (who knows what color), casual shirts at a party (not sure what style), etc. A "trendy" apartment, but who knows where the bathroom was. Gut feeling people tend to act w/o all the facts, and are comfortable following that instinct. "Thinker" people will choose something even if they HATE it, just because it "makes sense." Where as that makes no sense to a gut person. Thinkers are more "black and white" where as gut instinct feelers are more "gray area" people. But going with your selections... 1. Within 2. Big Picture 3. Gut Feeling 4. Spontaneous The Reflective Seeker of Truth. You are a passionate searcher of big-picture meaning and strive to help others with your empathetic listening skills. Socially, you are usually quiet, but can be a social butterfly when you feel like it, though it can be draining to do so for too long. You have a very silly and goofy side, enjoy people and need time to quietly reflect #1 Strength: Predicting Future Likelihoods #2 Strength: Expressing Social Feeling Predicting Future Likelihoods Predicting what is likely to happen, based on past events, themes, or what has historically been true. Deciding what will happen, based on past events. These predictions are usually spoken with con?dence and certainty. A thread or common idea is drawn from the past, and these ideas are used to decide what will happen in the future. Authorities and past situations are extremely important for deciding what will happen in the future. Expressing Social Feeling Setting an emotional tone, vibrant, energetic, or serious, etc. Concerned with the emotional environment as it?s happening -- the vibe of people at a party, the tone of a situation, other people?s responses. Setting the tone -- dramatic and serious, or lighthearted and a celebration. Emotional displays are important for knowing how others are feeling, whether bad or good. Someone talking in a monotone about feelings seems insincere. Feels should be shown, so they can be read by others. If that is your type, your #1 match would be... The Strong-Willed Go-Getter. You are a bold sculptor of the here-and-now in order to achieve immediate results following a logical system for making decisions. You add a fun, upbeat vibe to social events and are often the most gregarious person in the room. #1 Strength: Commander of Physical Space #2 Strength: Systematic/Rule Logic


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

How to choose your executive coach -1

Working Across Borders

Using your social media profiles to drive traffic

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.