Tweet

Competition VS Interdependence

Written by: Dianne Crampton

Article Overview: Competition is essential for business success. At the same time, internal competition damages your group intelligence, retards your growth and disrupts team morale. In this article, we explore what interdependent processes and leadership practices can do for your team.

Competition VS Interdependence

"May you live in interesting times." When I first heard this saying, it was difficult for me to understand why it was referred to as a curse.

Yet as the United States juggles the shift from Industrial to Information Age processes, talent management and succession dilemmas due to baby boomers retiring, and regular business issues such as foreign trade balances, mergers, acquisitions, balanced budgets, government stewardship, and systems-wide ecological imbalances, all we are left with is interesting times --and in my view extraordinary opportunities.

Born and raised in the United States, I have learned that competitive practices have made our country strong. Competition has given us a creative edge to invent new and better devices to feed, cloth, shelter and entertain our citizens.

As a culture we have embraced the idea, "if we want something, we can have it," resulting in the possibility of unlimited innovation. The downside, however, lies in self-interest that has long ago replaced the need for self-preservation. When this is encouraged and promoted within an organization, self-interest drives wedges in group synergy and effects collaborative values like trust, interdependence, genuineness, empathy, risk and success.

Competition is rooted in survival. It fosters polarization based on win - lose, right - wrong, us - them, predator - victim, and powerful - powerless concepts. From an organizational standpoint, competition might be most keenly felt within the team as struggles for power, or within an organization as struggles for information, supplies and resources. These struggles waste time, creativity, productivity, and profits. They also deepen competitive rifts and diminish overall group morale.

The truth is that the ultimate competitor will eventually stand alone, isolated by fear that something might be lost or taken away. This can be an expensive position because loyalty must be purchased with favors or money. Independent and lacking a foundation in community, the battle to the top may reap hollow reward. Is there a better way?

In 1987, I asked a question that ultimately produced an innovative way of looking at how people collectively achieve high levels of personal and group success. The question I asked was, "What is necessary to create an ethical, quality focused, successful, caring, and productive group of people?" The answer to that question emerged from an extensive study of group dynamics housed within three disciplines - education, psychology and business. The answer also produced a deeper understanding of successful collective endeavors based on a collaborative value structure. The collaborative values (trust, interdependence, genuineness, empathy,
risk and success -- TIGERS) resulted in shared power and shared resources contributing to highly effective collaborative ventures such as work teams, strategic alliances and companies like Federal Express and Yoshida Foods.

Both life and work experience had taught me that putting technically skilled people together on a task force didn't always result in a positive experience for all the parties involved. Depending on the level of competition and conflict the group either handled or avoided, work quality was ultimately affected. Team problems emerged from deep rooted group process problems and disappointed human interactions. The end result was that internally competitive cultures tended to avoid the expansive development of supervisors or managers equipped with the skills to motivate, inspire and lead workers.

Rewarded for directive leadership practices and getting the job done, many managers could not demonstrate communication and social skills that motivate workers to higher levels of performance without power plays or threats of loss. For example, many did not know how to be performance coaches. They lacked feedback skills that inspire work quality and personal pride. Synergy and group interdependence were foreign concepts. In fact, internal competition tended to discourage collaboration and encouraged aggressive and passive-aggressive power struggles from the boardroom to the break room.

Discoveries from the education, psychology and business group dynamic research also pointed out that people are rarely fired for not knowing how to perform work - given that they were hired based on skill competency or could be trained on the job. People were most often fired because of behaviors that violate a group's implied values, norms or standards. This pointed to an unspoken profit principle that a group's convictions on how business is conducted and how people are treated translates directly to work quality and service.

Examples of disruptive competitive practices are:

1.
Cutting remarks intended to make a person look foolish or inadequate among co-workers and peers. This form of verbal competition splits people into two divisions - winners and losers. The intended message is, "See how powerful I am, so back off." - and people do back off. They hold this person at a distance giving credence to the saying, "It's lonely at the top".

Collaborative leaders, however, do not find leadership to be a lonely place. They build success for themselves and for others. As a result, they are supported by their colleagues and stories of their achievements are told years after they are gone.

2.
Failing to reward or recognize a talented person for fear he or she is smarter, more talented or more valuable than the competitive leader. In internally competitive organizations where people claw their way up the corporate ladder, talented people are often held back by politically savvy yet less skilled leaders. Unfortunately, the organization is also held back for organizations learn through people who learn and organizations grow through people who grow.

3.
Watching a co-worker fail and holding a smug satisfaction that the competitor could have done a better job. Organizations that reward "we win" efforts foster the notion that serving one another is serving the company. It is through coaching, interdependence, and collaborative efforts that more work and higher productivity is achieved. A person who balks at helping others in order to fulfill his or her own agenda retards organizational success. This person lowers the bar and harms a company's ability to be competitive among similar companies - the place where competition matters.

For a free white paper on behaviors that build successful teams and behaviors that disrupt the collaborative process, subscribe to our monthly newsletter. We do not share or sell contact information and would be very interested in knowing what you believe is the most serious issue facing teams today.

Related Articles
  Bees, Nesting and Markets
  Team Interdependence When We Win I Win
  How Effective Are Your Work Habits?
  Leading Like TIGERS: A Successful Team Building Model
  Competitive Knowledge is a Dangerous Thing

Article Tags: business success, business team culture, group intelligence, interdependence, internal competition, leadership practices, productivity, successful team building, team building, team competition, team culture, team morale, tigers



Related Forum Posts
Re: Congratultations to GT! - Hi GT, Competition is great and i know I wouldn't be here without it, but it is not the main reason for posting and participating. But I admit, it is the trigger I need to get some work done. If there is none, i create one for myself and try to make it. First prize is ice cream.
Re: Is Google Search getting better or worse? - Competition and that too stiff is something I have always loved and being a true web user I hate spammers the same way and so I am very happy with the recent changes that Google has made and so I must say that it is getting better. I am happy because now we could be able to get and read fresh and unique content instead of the repetitive ones. Now the value of actual SEO will be seen as results now will be completely depend on the hard work SEO and strategies an internet marketing company will apply to get on top of search giant's ranking. surfing the web daily as addiction I have seen most of the webmasters asking several questions related to real time search and how they should commence now to get better and faster results, found lots of useful information and learned new strategies too.
Re: Help needed! - [quote="jeema":1rpkpkod]Hi, I’m a newly single mother who stays at home looking after my son. I have been writing for a long-long time but never thought to do something serious with it. I would like to try freelance copywriting, but don't know the first thing about it. How can I get started? Can anyone help me? I love writing and I could really-really use the extra cash- raising a young child alone really hits the wallet pocket. I appreciate any replies, and hope that I may be able to help in return sometime soon. Thank you very much.[/quote:1rpkpkod] Hi, Jeema It's easier than ever for writers (non-fiction writers, anyway!) to get work these days, via such sites as elance.com (they are who I do work for.) There are plenty of freelance sites on the web, where prospective customers post what they need, and prospective workers "bid" on the jobs, and then the customer chooses which writer he wants to do the work. There's lots of competition, but the wheat soon separates from the chaff and if you can write well, you can usually find steady employment. Competition drives down the price that you're able to charge, however, unless you have niche expertise such as technical or legal writing. PM me for some free advice, if you'd like!


Share this article with your friends. Fund someone's dream.

Leave a comment below or share on the left and you'll help support entrepreneurs in Africa through our partnership with Kiva. Over $50,000 raised and counting - Please keep sharing! Learn more.

Tweet

Newsletter

Get advice & tips from famous business
owners, new articles by entrepreneur
experts, my latest website updates, &
special sneak peaks at what's to come!

Name:
Email:

Popular Articles

Tips to Take Control of Credit Card Debt

Top 5 Tips for Better Online Ads

Suggestions

Email us your ideas on how to make our
website more valuable! Thank you Sharon
from Toronto Salsa Lessons / Classes for
your suggestions to make the newsletter
look like the website and profile younger
entrepreneurs like Jennifer Lopez.