"The world, as Thomas L. Friedman contends, may well be flat, but peaks and valleys remain. Even viewed from China and India, the twin steamrollers Mr. Friedman sees leveling the landscape of the new economy, Silicon Valley still occupies lofty heights.
In centers of technology around the world, whether established or emergent, “Silicon Valley” is a metonym for an entire ecosystem of technology and finance, with its own infrastructure of support services and social networks—slued together by a culture that lionizes risk-takers, rewards out-of-the-box innovators, and forgives failure.
Despite its obvious success, the model has not been successfully replicated anywhere: not in Beijing, not in Bangalore, not in Stockholm or Tel Aviv—and not for lack of trying.
To be sure, innovation, talent, and capital have spread globally. A tangible link to the Valley—whether through technology, capital, or physical presence—is no longer the sine qua non for a high-tech firm, if it ever was. None of India’s three software outsourcing giants, Infosys, TCS, and Wipro, had roots in the Valley: no venture backing from Sand Hill Road, no Stanford spin-off technologies.
But for technology entrepreneurs the world over, the words of Mirabilis chairman and founding investor Yossi Vardi probably still ring true. “Silicon Valley was the Mecca, it is still the Mecca, and it will be the Mecca,” says the Tel Aviv-based Mr. Vardi, whose company created the popular chat client ICQ, acquired by AOL in 1998 for a reported $400 million.
Making the Move
If the Valley is Mecca, then German-born Stefan Roever, 40, is one pilgrim who has made the Holy City home. Only months after the company he co-founded, Stuttgart-based Brokat Technologies, went belly-up in 2001, he was at it again with a new company, Navio Systems, based in Cupertino. Brokat made software for Internet and mobile phone financial transactions. Mr. Roever’s new company makes digital rights management software for Internet commerce.
Mr. Roever was named one of the World Economic Forum’s 2006 Technology Pioneers. “I had seen the environment in Silicon Valley and I was pretty sure that if I was going to start over I would want to do it here,” he says. “The entire environment is conducive to entrepreneurship and innovation.”
In Germany, “profit is a dirty word,” according to Mr. Roever, and startups are stymied by an overgrown regulatory environment, bureaucracy, and onerous taxes. “Very few people in Germany have ever built or been part of a team that created a global technology software enterprise,” he says. “If a new global business like a Yahoo or a Google is going to be built, chances are still pretty good that it is going to be built [in Silicon Valley].”
But Valley culture has been transplanted to parts of Old Europe, such as England, and it is showing clear signs of taking root in other dynamic economies. Emulation of the Valley formula is deliberate and deferential, helped along by hundreds of European, Indian, and Chinese returnees, sometime dwellers of the Valley’s Santa Clara County who headed home to start up tech businesses. But no one in China or India needs to be reminded of the Valley’s importance. “There will never be another Silicon Valley,” says Sridhar Mitta, the managing director of e4e, an Indo-U.S. software outsourcing company.
Valley fever burns particularly hot in China. High-tech zones in major Chinese cities vie to be recognized as “the Silicon Valley of China.” In northwestern Beijing’s Haidian district—a leading contender for that title, with its concentration of top universities, technology parks, and new economy companies—one upscale housing development even calls itself Guigu, Chinese for Silicon Valley."